Kaitlin and Katie's Picks 2 is a CD containing cover versions of select songs, as well as VGM with added-in lyrics. New to the CD is that it features commentary from Kaitlin and Katie before and after each song. It contains 30 tracks
| Track # | Track Name | Original Source | Sung By |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2U | David Guetta and Justin Bieber | Zac |
| 2 | Marmalade | Macklemore and Lil Yatchy | Cyrus, Trev, Kaitlin, Anna |
| 3 | All Star | Smash Mouth | Dan, Hosley, Elliot, Nick R. |
| 4 | Friends | Hyper Potions/Sonic Mania | Kaitlin, Katie, Casha |
| 5 | Theme Song | Family Guy | Anna, Ryan O, Elliot, Austin, Jaxon, Macy |
| 6 | All Summer Long | Kid Rock | Dan, Jonathan, Keagan |
| 7 | Body Like a Back Road | Sam Hunt | Nate S |
| 8 | The Campfire Song Song | SpongeBob Squarepants | Jarrett, Alex S. |
| 9 | Havana | Camila Cabello and Young Thug | Kaitlin, Braeden |
| 10 | I Don't Wanna Miss A Thing | Aerosmith | Zack, Nick R, Hosley, Dan |
| 11 | The Lion Sleeps Tonight | The Tokens | Ryan H, Zach M, Savannah, Arika |
| 12 | Safety Dance | Men Without Hats | Jarrett, Alex S, Zac |
| 13 | Water Under the Bridge | Adele | Kaitlin |
| 14 | The Mine Song | LazyTown | Jonathan B. |
| 15 | That's What I Like | Bruno Mars | Dan |
| 16 | Plessie's Plunging Falls | Super Mario 3D World | Maddie M, Olivia, Macy, Shannon |
| 17 | Wish I Knew You | The Revivalists | Jake C, Jarrett |
| 18 | The Legendary Air Ride Machine | Kirby Air Ride (remix from Super Smash Bros. Brawl) | Kaitlin, Anna, Keagan, Ryan H, Patrick |
| 19 | Big Things Too | VeggieTales | Alison, Aj |
| 20 | Get Lucky | Daft Punk and Pharrell Williams | Jaime, Patrick, Ethan D, Matt C, Brady |
| 21 | My Immortal | Evanescence | Katie |
| 22 | Scary Monsters and Nice Sprites | Skrillex | Alex T, Nathaniel |
| 23 | My Songs Know What You Did In The Dark | Fall Out Boy | Aj, Dan, Aaron |
| 24 | Theme Song | Drake and Josh | Steven H, Elliot |
| 25 | I Don't Wanna Live Forever | Zayn and Taylor Swift | Brad L and Maddie W |
| 26 | Don't Stop Me Now | Queen | Chris T, Jake P, Dan, Lane |
| 27 | Splattack | Splatoon | Savannah, Emma H, Laura |
| 28 | This Is How We Roll | Florida Georgia Line | Tyler S, Nate S, Nick C |
| 29 | Side to Side | Ariana Grande | Maddie M, Trinity |
| 30 | We Are Young | Fun. | All |